Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, UMT Smart Tool earns from qualifying purchases. This guide is built from product listings and maker specifications, not from our own hands-on testing. Prices are approximate and can change, so check the current price before you buy. Last updated: November 10, 2026.
“Best outdoor pillows” means different things depending on where the pillow will live. A pillow on a covered porch mainly needs fabric that will not fade in indirect sun. A pillow on an open deck or by a pool has to shrug off rain, dry fast, and resist mildew. And if you already own covers you like, the smartest buy may be a waterproof insert rather than another finished pillow. This guide is organized by those jobs, so you can start with how exposed your seating is, then compare the strongest option in each role.
In this guide
Quick Picks
The short version: six outdoor pillows and inserts we would look at first, one per use case.
| Pick | Type | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Pillow Perfect Reversible Floral Stripe (Annie) | Square throw pillows, 18.5 in, set of 2 | All-round patio color that flips between two looks |
| Sorra Home x Sunbrella Lumbar Pillows | Lumbar pillows, set of 2 | Genuine Sunbrella fabric and the longest fade resistance |
| Arden Selections Outdoor Toss Pillow | Square toss pillows, 16 in, 2-pack | Everyday value with a PFAS-free water-repellent finish |
| Greendale Home Fashions Outdoor Accent Pillows | Square accent pillows, 17 in, set of 2 | Overstuffed comfort with recycled fill |
| JMGBird Outdoor Throw Pillows with Inserts | Complete pillows, 18 in, 2-pack | Ready-to-use sets with waterproof covers and inserts included |
| Phantoscope Premium Outdoor Pillow Inserts | Waterproof inserts, 18 in, pack of 4 | Refreshing covers you already own |
Our Picks
1. Pillow Perfect Reversible Floral Stripe (Annie), 18.5 x 18.5 Inches, Set of 2 — Best Overall
Pillow Perfect is a specialist in indoor/outdoor soft furnishings, and this reversible set shows why it leads the list. Each 18.5-inch square pillow pairs a floral face with a coordinating stripe on the back, so one purchase gives you two looks — handy when you want a seasonal refresh without buying new pillows. The shell is a weather- and fade-resistant outdoor fabric, the fill is a plush polyester fill (Pillow Perfect uses 100% recycled polyester fill across its outdoor line), and the corded edges keep the shape looking tailored on a sofa or loveseat.
The trade-offs are care and closure: the cover is sewn shut rather than zippered, so cleaning means spot cleaning or a gentle hose-down and air dry rather than a machine wash. Polyester outdoor fabric also sits a step below solution-dyed acrylic for multi-season fade resistance in full, all-day sun. For most patios and covered decks, though, the size, the two-in-one styling and the specialist maker make this the set we would buy first.
2. Sorra Home x Sunbrella Indoor/Outdoor Lumbar Pillows, Set of 2, Canvas Natural Ivory & Taupe — Best Sunbrella Fabric
If fading is your main enemy, this is the pick. The covers are genuine Sunbrella — the solution-dyed acrylic whose color is built into the fiber before weaving, which is why it is the benchmark fabric for cushions that sit in direct sun season after season. The set pairs two neutral lumbar pillows (one Canvas Natural Ivory, one Canvas Taupe, model AMPS114651), each 18 inches long, filled with polyester fiber for a plush sit against deep-seat chairs and outdoor sofas. The listing also notes Global Recycled Standard certified content, with at least 50% recycled material.
Sunbrella carries a premium-tier price per pillow, and a lumbar shape is a support-and-accent piece rather than the big square layer most people start with — many buyers will pair this set with plainer square pillows. Neutrals are also the only route here; if you want bold pattern, look at the Pillow Perfect or JMGBird sets instead. For a sunny, uncovered seat where you want the fabric to outlast everything around it, this is the strongest choice.
3. Arden Selections Outdoor Toss Pillow, 16 x 16 Inches, 2-Pack, Blue Garden Floral — Best Value
Arden Selections is the outdoor cushion brand from Central Garden & Pet, and its toss pillows are the workhorse option in this guide. The 16-inch pair (model 100217494) uses long-lasting outdoor polyester fabric with a PFAS-free C0 water-repellent treatment, and the listing rates the pillows UV-resistant, water-resistant and fade-resistant. Inside is a soft polyfiber fill made with recycled content. The smaller 16-inch format suits dining chairs, porch rockers and smaller loveseats where an 18.5-inch pillow would crowd the seat.
The compromises are size and fabric tier: 16 inches reads as an accent rather than a lounging pillow, and a surface water-repellent treatment is not the same as a waterproof shell — in a downpour these should come under cover. Printed polyester will also fade sooner than solution-dyed acrylic over multiple summers of direct sun. At a budget-friendly tier for a two-pack from an established outdoor brand, it is the easiest way to dress several chairs at once.
4. Greendale Home Fashions Outdoor Accent Pillows, 17 Inches, Esprit, Set of 2 — Best Recycled Fill
Greendale’s square accent pillows (model OC4803S2-ESPRIT) lean into loft: each 17-inch pillow is overstuffed with 100% soft polyester fill made from recycled post-consumer plastic bottles, inside a 100% polyester shell the maker describes as UV-resistant and rated for fade, stain and water resistance. The Esprit floral pattern gives a traditional garden look that works on wicker and wood benches, and the generous fill makes these better back-support pillows than flatter decorative squares.
Overstuffing cuts both ways: on a shallow chair seat, a plump 17-inch pillow can push you forward, so measure seat depth before ordering. The cover is sewn closed, so care is spot cleaning only, and as with other printed polyester shells, deep shade or off-season storage will extend the color’s life. Choose this set if you want a fuller, softer lean-back feel and like the idea of fill diverted from plastic bottles.
5. JMGBird Outdoor Throw Pillows with Inserts, 18 x 18 Inches, Blue Mandala, 2-Pack — Best Complete Set
Most outdoor pillow shopping splits into covers here, inserts there. JMGBird’s set (model JMG-003) skips that: the 2-pack includes both the waterproof decorative covers and the premium inserts to fill them, in an 18 x 18 inch square with a blue mandala flower pattern. The covers zip closed, so they come off for cleaning or a seasonal swap, and the waterproof finish is aimed at exactly the splash-and-shower exposure a patio set actually gets.
As a smaller brand, JMGBird does not publish the fabric pedigree of a Sunbrella or the fabric testing detail of the bigger cushion makers, so treat the waterproofing as splash-grade protection rather than leave-out-all-winter armor. Pattern choice is also bolder than the neutrals elsewhere in this guide. But as a single purchase that lands on the porch ready to use — no separate insert order, no size guessing — it is the most convenient set here.
6. Phantoscope Premium Outdoor Pillow Inserts, 18 x 18 Inches, Pack of 4, White — Best Waterproof Inserts
Sometimes the covers are fine and the fill is the problem — indoor inserts left outside turn heavy, flat and musty. Phantoscope’s outdoor inserts fix that at the source: the pack of four 18 x 18 inch forms uses a waterproof shell around hypoallergenic fill, so the insert itself sheds water instead of wicking it into the stuffing. The maker calls them dual-usage pillows — plain white and neat enough to sit on a bench without a cover in a pinch, though they are really meant to live inside your decorative covers.
An insert is only as good as its fit: for a plump look in an 18-inch cover, these are sized to fill it directly, but if your covers are 16 or 20 inches, order the matching insert size rather than forcing it. You also get no color or pattern here — the decorating still comes from covers you supply. If your outdoor covers are worth keeping, four waterproof forms are the cheapest route to pillows that dry fast and stay fresh.
Best Picks by Category
- Square throw pillows: Pillow Perfect Reversible Floral Stripe (Annie), Set of 2 — reversible floral/stripe faces in the classic 18.5-inch size.
- Sunbrella fabric: Sorra Home x Sunbrella Lumbar Pillows, Set of 2 — genuine solution-dyed acrylic for maximum fade resistance.
- Value 2-pack: Arden Selections Outdoor Toss Pillow, 16 Inches — PFAS-free water-repellent finish and recycled polyfiber fill.
- Recycled fill: Greendale Home Fashions Outdoor Accent Pillows, Esprit, Set of 2 — overstuffed with fill made from recycled bottles.
- Complete set with inserts: JMGBird Outdoor Throw Pillows with Inserts, 2-Pack — waterproof covers and inserts in a single purchase.
- Waterproof inserts: Phantoscope Premium Outdoor Pillow Inserts, Pack of 4 — waterproof shells that keep existing covers usable outdoors.
Buying by role keeps the budget honest: money spent on Sunbrella fabric pays off on an uncovered deck, while a covered porch can put the same money toward more pillows instead.
How to Choose
Fabric: solution-dyed acrylic vs outdoor polyester
The fabric decides how long the color lasts. Solution-dyed acrylic such as Sunbrella has pigment through the whole fiber, so it resists fading, water and mildew the longest and suits uncovered, full-sun seating. Outdoor polyester costs less and performs well under a roof or in partial shade, but printed patterns fade faster. Olefin (polypropylene) sits between the two and dries quickly. Match the fabric tier to your exposure, not to the prettiest pattern.
Water resistance vs waterproof
Water-resistant and water-repellent shells shed splashes and light rain, then dry in the sun; truly waterproof shells and inserts keep the fill dry in heavier rain. No throw pillow is meant to sit in standing water or stay out through a storm season — even the best fill eventually mildews if it never dries. In wet climates, prioritize waterproof inserts, and store pillows under cover between uses.
Fill and drying speed
Outdoor pillows are filled with polyester fiber because it does not absorb much water and dries far faster than foam or down, which have no place outside. Recycled polyfill performs the same job with a smaller footprint. Loft matters too: overstuffed pillows give real back support on deep seats, while flatter pillows are purely decorative. After rain, stand pillows on edge to drain and dry both faces.
Size, shape and count
Square 18-inch pillows are the standard layer for sofas and loveseats; 16-inch pillows fit dining chairs and small benches; lumbar rectangles (roughly 12 x 18–20 inches) add lower-back support and a horizontal accent. A common formula is one lumbar per sofa plus a square at each corner. Always check the pillow against your seat depth — a big pillow on a shallow chair steals sitting room.
Covers, inserts and closures
Finished pillows with sewn-shut covers are simplest but spot-clean only. Zippered covers come off for washing and let you change patterns seasonally over the same inserts. If you buy inserts separately, match the insert to the cover size — the same size for a standard fit, or 2 inches larger for a plump, designer-style fill. Waterproof inserts are the upgrade that makes any cover genuinely outdoor-safe.
Care and off-season storage
Brush off dirt before it sets, spot clean with mild soap and water, and let pillows dry fully before stacking them. Bleach tolerance varies by fabric — solution-dyed acrylic usually allows it, prints often do not — so follow the maker’s label. In winter or long wet spells, store pillows in a deck box or indoors; UV and freeze-thaw cycles age even performance fabric eventually.
Choosing Colors and Patterns for Your Outdoor Space
Outdoor pillows work best when they connect to something that is already there, such as the cushions, a rug, the umbrella or the plants around the seating area. A simple approach is to pick one dominant color that matches the main cushions, then add one or two accents that appear elsewhere in the space. That keeps a patio looking intentional rather than cluttered.
Solids and small-scale patterns are the most flexible choices. Large bold prints can look great on a single accent pillow but quickly overwhelm a small seating area when repeated. Stripes are forgiving because they pair with almost everything, while florals work best when one of the colors echoes a nearby planter or fabric.
Color also affects how a pillow ages in the sun. Deep, saturated colors can show fading sooner than neutrals, and light colors show dirt and pollen more easily. If your seating area gets strong afternoon sun, neutral and medium tones tend to look good for longer. Mixing sizes, such as two squares and one lumbar, adds visual interest without needing more patterns.
Dealing With Mildew and Humid Climates
Moisture trapped inside a pillow is the main cause of that musty smell. In humid regions, even a water-resistant cover will not prevent dampness from the air, and dew can soak the fill overnight. Fast-draining fill, breathable fabric and good airflow around the pillow matter more than waterproof claims.
After rain, shake the pillows and stand them on their edges so air can circulate, rather than leaving them stacked or lying flat. If you notice early signs of mildew, such as faint spots or odor, act quickly: brush off the surface, wash the cover according to its care label and let everything dry completely in the sun and wind before putting it back.
- Avoid storing damp pillows in sealed bags or bins.
- Keep pillows off bare, wet ground and away from sprinkler spray.
- Rotate pillows so no single one stays in a shaded, damp corner.
Wind, Pets and Practical Everyday Issues
Lightweight pillows can blow around in a breeze, especially on open decks and rooftops. If wind is a problem, look for covers with a snug fit, heavier fill or ties that anchor the pillow to a chair or bench. Some people keep a small storage bench nearby so the pillows can be tucked away quickly when a storm approaches.
Pets are another factor. Cats and dogs can scratch, chew or leave fur and dirt on fabric, so a tightly woven cover that wipes clean is helpful. Zippered covers that come off easily are better than sewn-shut pillows when pets or children use the furniture regularly.
Budget Versus Premium Outdoor Pillows
Price differences usually reflect fabric quality, stitching and fill. Premium pillows tend to use more fade-resistant yarns, finer seams and better inserts that keep their shape. Budget pillows can still look good and perform well in a covered or lightly used space, but they may fade or flatten sooner in direct sun and heavy weather.
A practical approach is to spend more on pillows that sit in full sun or get daily use, and save on accent pillows in covered or shaded areas. If you are decorating seasonally, lower-cost covers make it easy to change the look without a big investment. Whatever you choose, check the care instructions and the fabric description before buying, because those details tell you more about longevity than the price tag.
Questions to Answer Before You Buy Outdoor Pillows
Start by thinking about where the pillows will live. A fully covered porch is far gentler on fabric than an open deck that bakes in afternoon sun and takes every rainstorm. The more exposure, the more you should lean toward fade-resistant, quick-drying and easy-to-clean options, and the more seriously you should consider bringing pillows inside during bad weather.
Next, check what you are actually buying. Some listings sell covers only, some sell covers with inserts, and some sell inserts alone. Confirm the dimensions of the finished pillow, not just the cover, and compare them with your furniture so the pillows are not oversized for the seat. Look for details such as zipper closures, which make washing easier, and reinforced seams that handle repeated use.
- Is the fabric described as outdoor-rated, or is that claim missing?
- Does the listing say whether the fill is quick-drying?
- Can the covers be machine washed, or are they spot-clean only?
- How many pieces come in the set, and do they match in size?
Finally, think about seasons. If you live where winters are harsh, plan on storing pillows indoors or in a sealed deck box, and buy accordingly. A few well-chosen pillows that you protect will look better for longer than a large stack left to weather unprotected.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can outdoor pillows stay outside in the rain?
Brief rain, yes; soaking weather, not indefinitely. Water-resistant pillows shed splashes and dry out in the sun, but repeated soaking eventually reaches any fill. Waterproof inserts like the Phantoscope set above handle wet conditions best. For storms and winter, bring pillows under cover or into a deck box — it is the single habit that most extends their life.
What is the difference between Sunbrella and regular outdoor fabric?
Sunbrella is solution-dyed acrylic: the color is added while the fiber is liquid, so it runs through the yarn rather than sitting on the surface. That is why it resists fading, mildew and water longer than coated or printed polyester. The trade-off is price, which is why polyester picks like Arden and Greendale still make sense for shaded or covered seating.
What size outdoor pillow should I buy?
Start with the furniture. Outdoor sofas and deep-seat chairs take 18- to 20-inch squares plus a lumbar; dining chairs look and feel better with 16-inch pillows; benches often pair one lumbar with a square at each end. Measure seat depth first — the pillow should support your back without pushing you off the front edge of the seat.
Do I need special inserts for outdoor pillow covers?
Yes, if the covers will live outside. Indoor inserts absorb water, dry slowly and mildew. Outdoor inserts use a water-resistant or waterproof shell over polyester fill that sheds moisture and dries quickly. Match the insert size to the cover, or go 2 inches larger for a fuller look.
How do I stop outdoor pillows from fading?
Choose solution-dyed fabric for full-sun spots, rotate pillows so all faces share the exposure, and store them out of the sun when the seating is unused for weeks. No fabric is fade-proof, but the gap between solution-dyed acrylic and printed polyester is measured in seasons, not weeks.
How do I clean outdoor pillows?
Brush off loose dirt, spot clean with mild soap and lukewarm water, rinse, and air dry completely. Zippered covers may be machine washable per the label; sewn-shut pillows are spot-clean only. Never store a damp pillow — trapped moisture, not rain, is what causes most mildew.
Can I use indoor pillows outside on a covered porch?
You can for short, dry periods, but indoor fabrics are not designed for humidity, sunlight and temperature swings. Even under a roof, damp air and blowing rain can cause fading and mildew. If you want to use them outdoors, bring them inside when you are not using the space.
How many throw pillows does a patio sofa need?
Two to four pillows suit a standard outdoor sofa, with a mix of sizes for interest. Too many pillows leave little room to sit and add work when you need to store them. For a loveseat, two or three is usually plenty. Add lumbar pillows to chairs for back support.
How long do outdoor pillows last?
It depends on the fabric, the amount of sun and how often they are stored. Good outdoor fabrics in a sheltered spot can last several seasons, while budget fabrics in full sun may fade within a year or two. Cleaning them regularly and storing them in bad weather extends their life.
How do I prevent outdoor pillows from getting moldy?
Keep them dry and allow airflow. Stand them on edge after rain, let them dry fully before storing them and avoid sealed plastic. Wash covers regularly with mild soap and make sure the fill dries completely. Pillows with quick-drying fill and breathable fabric are less prone to mildew.
Bottom Line
Buy for your exposure first and your pattern second. For most patios, the Pillow Perfect Annie set is our first recommendation — a reversible 18.5-inch pair from a specialist maker. On an uncovered deck in hard sun, step up to the Sorra Home x Sunbrella lumbar set; on a budget, the Arden 2-pack; and if your covers are still good, the Phantoscope waterproof inserts are the smartest money in this guide. Check dimensions and the current price before you order.




