A claw hammer drives nails with the face and pulls them with the claw. Weight, claw shape and handle material change how it feels in use. A curved claw gives leverage for pulling nails, while a straight rip claw is also used to split boards apart and in demolition work.
The six hammers below run from 16 ounce models with curved and rip claws to a 20 ounce framing hammer with a squared face. Weights, materials and features come from each listing page and are the makers’ own claims. We have not used these hammers ourselves. Where a listing contradicts itself, we say so.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links below are affiliate links, and they do not change the product information we give.
What to Look For
| Feature | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Weight | Heavier heads drive larger nails, lighter ones suit trim work |
| Claw style | Curved for pulling, straight rip for prying and demolition |
| Face | Smooth leaves fewer marks, milled grips the nail head |
| Handle | Steel, fiberglass and composite grips feel different |
Specs at a Glance
| Hammer | Weight and claw | Face | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| ESTWING E3-16S | 16 oz; rip claw | Smooth | Forged in one piece; shock reduction grip |
| ESTWING E3-16C | 16 oz; curved claw | Smooth | Forged in one piece; 13 in long |
| Klein H80920S | 20 oz; straight claw | Smooth, squared | Magnetic nail starter; dual side nail pullers |
| IRWIN 1954889 | 16 oz; claw | Smooth | Fiberglass handle; forged steel head |
| Titan 63020 | 16 oz; claw | Not stated | 13 in fiberglass handle; head material conflict |
| JORGENSEN 60101 | 16 oz; rip claw | Milled | Magnetic nail holder; side nail puller |
The 6 Best Claw Hammers
1. ESTWING Rip Hammer, 16oz Smooth Face (E3-16S)
A 16 ounce rip claw hammer that the maker says is forged in one piece from American steel. It has a smooth face and a molded shock reduction grip, which the maker says cuts impact vibration by 70 percent. The listing also says it is made in the USA and aimed at framers, roofers and carpenters. The detail table shows alloy steel for both head and handle.
Suits: general carpentry and light demolition. Strengths: one-piece forged build. Weaknesses: the vibration figure is the maker’s own claim. Skip it if you want a fiberglass handle.
View ESTWING Rip Hammer, 16oz Smooth Face, Shock Reduction Grip, E3-16S on Amazon
2. ESTWING Curved Claw Hammer, 16 oz Smooth Face (E3-16C)
The curved claw version of the same 16 ounce Estwing line, listed at 13 inches long. The maker describes the curve as giving added torque for pulling and prying nails or boards. It shares the one-piece forged build and the shock reduction grip with the rip model.
Suits: pulling nails and general repairs. Strengths: curved claw leverage. Weaknesses: less suited to splitting boards than a rip claw. Skip it if you do framing demolition.
View ESTWING Curved Claw Hammer, 16 oz Smooth Face, Shock Reduction Grip, E3-16C on Amazon
3. Klein Tools H80920S Smooth Face Framing Hammer, 20-Ounce
A 20 ounce forged steel framing hammer with a straight claw, an extra-large squared strike face and dual side nail pullers. The maker says the large face lowers missed strikes in tight spaces. A magnetic nail starter lets you place a nail with one hand, and the grips are described as cushioned. The listing gives a length of 16.13 inches.
Suits: framing and heavier nailing. Strengths: magnetic starter and a large face. Weaknesses: 20 ounces is heavy for small jobs. Skip it if you want a light trim hammer.
View Klein Tools H80920S Smooth Face Framing Hammer with Straight Claw, 20-Ounce on Amazon
4. IRWIN Fiberglass General Purpose Claw Hammer, 16 oz (1954889)
A 16 ounce hammer with a forged steel head, a smooth face and a fiberglass handle that the maker says absorbs vibration. The grip is called ProTouch and the handle has a rounded hybrid shape with a curved base and a hardened end cap. The listing size is 12.75 inches long.
Suits: household repairs. Strengths: fiberglass handle and a smooth face. Weaknesses: the listing gives no claw detail beyond the title. Skip it if you want an all-steel hammer.
View IRWIN Hammer, Fiberglass, General Purpose, Claw, 16 oz. (1954889) on Amazon
5. Titan 63020 16oz Claw Hammer, Fiberglass Handle
A 16 ounce claw hammer with a 13 inch fiberglass handle, a textured cushion grip and a limited lifetime warranty. The listing is not consistent on the head: the title says forged steel, while the details table says cast iron. Check the product description before you buy if the head material matters to you.
Suits: a basic toolbox hammer. Strengths: a stated warranty and a textured grip. Weaknesses: conflicting head material and few other details. Skip it if you need a confirmed forged head.
6. JORGENSEN 16 oz One-piece Forged Rip Claw Hammer
A 16 ounce straight rip claw hammer made from one-piece forged, heat-treated carbon steel. It has a milled face, a magnetic nail holder, a side nail puller and a TPR coated shock absorbing grip. The listing gives 13 inches long and names Hangzhou Greatstar as the manufacturer.
Suits: nailing and prying. Strengths: milled face and a magnetic holder. Weaknesses: a milled face can mark soft wood. Skip it if you want a smooth face.
View JORGENSEN 16 oz One-piece Forged Rip Claw Hammer with Magnetic Nail Holder on Amazon
Care and Setup
- Wear eye protection when you strike metal.
- Check that the head sits firmly on the handle before use.
- Wipe the head dry and store it away from damp.
- Keep the face clean so it does not slip off the nail.
Mistakes to Avoid
- Using a 20 ounce framing hammer for small trim nails.
- Choosing a milled face for work where marks show.
- Skipping the listing details when two fields disagree.
- Striking hardened surfaces with a general purpose hammer.
Claw Hammer FAQ
What is the difference between a curved and a rip claw?
A curved claw is shaped for pulling nails with leverage. A straight rip claw is also used to pry and split boards apart.
Smooth face or milled face?
A smooth face leaves fewer marks on the surface. A milled face has a textured pattern that the makers say helps it hold the nail head.
The Short Version
For a forged rip claw, the ESTWING E3-16S. For a curved claw, the ESTWING E3-16C. For framing, the Klein H80920S. For a fiberglass handle, the IRWIN. For a basic hammer with a warranty, the Titan, once you confirm the head. For a milled face and magnetic holder, the JORGENSEN.