A nail puller removes nails, including headless and bent ones, without wrecking the surrounding wood. The two common styles are the cats paw, a bar with a sharp claw you tap under the nail, and end cutting pliers that bite the nail and lever it out. The choices that matter are length, claw shape and weight.
The six tools below include a forged one-piece cats paw, a three-bar set, a rocking-head design, a short wood-handled puller, a double-ended bar and a pair of pliers. Sizes and weights come from each listing and are the makers’ own claims. We have not used these tools ourselves. Where a listing disagrees with itself, we say so.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links below are affiliate links, and they do not change the product information we give.
What to Look For
| Feature | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Style | Cats paws dig under flush nails; pliers grab nails that stand proud |
| Length | A longer handle gives more leverage but is harder to use in tight spots |
| Claw shape | A thin claw reaches headless nails with less wood damage |
| Material | One-piece forged steel is the usual sign of a tough bar |
| Weight | Lighter bars are easier to carry all day |
Specs at a Glance
| Tool | Length listed | Weight listed | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| ESTWING PC360G | 15 in title; 14 in table | 1.1 lb | Forged in one piece; thin claw |
| Bates 3 pack | 8, 10 and 12 in | 2.31 lb set | Red-coated handles; three cats paws |
| WORKPRO 13 in | 13 in | 1.41 lb | Rocking head; I-beam handle; black coating |
| Hultafors ATLE | 8 in | 1.3 lb | Wooden grip; 1 year warranty |
| Real Steel 10 in | 10 in | 14 oz | Carbon steel; magnetic nail holder; I-beam |
| Bates 11 in pliers | 11 in | 1.7 lb | End cutting; plastic coated grip |
The 6 Best Nail Pullers
1. ESTWING Pro Claw Nail Puller, 15 in (PC360G)
A cats paw bar forged in one piece from solid steel, with a thin claw the maker says removes headless nails with little wood damage and reaches hard-to-reach places. The title says 15 inches, while the details table says 14 inches and the dimensions are 14 x 3 x 14 inches, so check the length before ordering. The listing weight is 1.1 pounds.
Suits: demolition and trim work. Strengths: one-piece forging and a slim claw. Weaknesses: a conflicting length. Skip it if you need a small, pocket-sized puller.
View ESTWING Pro Claw Nail Puller, 15″ Steel Prying Tool, PC360G on Amazon
2. Bates Pry Bar Nail Puller Set, 3 Pack, 8, 10 and 12 in
Three cats paw bars in 8, 10 and 12 inch lengths with red-coated steel handles. The maker describes strong steel tips for removing nails, tacks and staples and suggests furniture repair, flooring and demolition. The set weighs 2.31 pounds by the listing.
Suits: a toolbox with all three sizes. Strengths: three lengths in one purchase. Weaknesses: the page gives no steel grade. Skip it if you only need one bar.
View Bates- Pry Bar Nail Puller Set, 3 Pack, 8″/10″/12″, Nail Puller Tool, Small Pry Bar on Amazon
3. WORKPRO 13 in Nail Puller Cats Paw Pry Bar
A 13 inch cats paw with a rocking head, a flat striking face and an I-beam handle. The maker says the pointed end digs into wood and the rounded rocker lifts nails without marking a finished surface, including headless and gun nails. A black electrophoretic coating is listed against rust. It weighs 1.41 pounds.
Suits: pulling nails from the back or from flooring. Strengths: a rocker end and a striking face. Weaknesses: longer than the pocket-sized options. Skip it if you want a short, light bar.
View WORKPRO 13″ Nail Puller, Cats Paw Pry Bar, Nail Remover Tool, Crowbar on Amazon
4. Hultafors Tools 820030U Nail Puller ATLE
An 8 inch red-finished steel puller with a wooden grip that you can pair with a carpenter’s hammer or use on its own. The maker says it pulls 5 inch nails, even when the head is off or buried, and the compact size fits a pocket or toolbox. It weighs 1.3 pounds and carries a 1 year warranty.
Suits: a carpenter’s pouch. Strengths: a compact shape with a warranty. Weaknesses: short for stubborn nails. Skip it if you need long leverage.
View Hultafors Tools 820030U Nail Puller ATLE on Amazon
5. Real Steel 10 in Double Ended Nail Puller Cats Paw
A 10 inch carbon steel bar forged in one piece, with a claw for embedded or headless nails, three beveled nail slots, dual strike zones and a magnetic nail holder. The maker says the I-beam shape is 20 percent lighter than ordinary crowbars, which is its own comparison. It weighs 14 ounces.
Suits: light demolition. Strengths: a low weight and a magnetic holder. Weaknesses: the weight claim is unverified. Skip it if you prefer plain pliers.
View Real Steel 10″ Double Ended Nail Puller Cats Paw Pry Bar Construction (0691) on Amazon
6. Bates 11 in Nail Puller Pliers
End cutting pliers, 11 inches long, with a soft plastic coated grip, described by the maker as made from high carbon steel that resists rust. The material field says iron, so the two statements differ. The listing says it pulls nails even when the head is damaged. It weighs 1.7 pounds.
Suits: pulling nails that stand above the surface. Strengths: a firm grab on damaged heads. Weaknesses: the material wording conflicts. Skip it if the nails are flush or headless.
Care and Setup
- Wear eye protection when striking a cats paw with a hammer.
- Slip a scrap of thin wood under the heel to protect finished surfaces.
- Wipe the tool dry and store it away from damp areas.
- Pull nails straight out when you can, to limit wood damage.
Mistakes to Avoid
- Using pliers on a nail that has no head above the surface.
- Striking a bar that the maker does not describe as a striking tool.
- Trusting a length in the title without checking the table.
- Prying against fragile trim without a backing piece.
Nail Puller FAQ
What is a cats paw?
A cats paw is a bar with a curved, sharp claw. You tap the claw under a nail or head and rock the bar to lift it.
Which is best for headless nails?
The makers of the ESTWING, WORKPRO and Real Steel bars describe headless-nail removal. The pliers need part of the nail to stand proud.
The Short Version
For a forged one-piece bar, the ESTWING. For three lengths, the Bates set. For a rocking head, the WORKPRO. For a short pouch tool, the Hultafors. For a light double-ended bar, the Real Steel. For pliers, the Bates 11 inch.